Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Election Heat !

I have been following the run-up to the Nominations for the US Presidential elections since December and must say it's been quite an interesting experience.Although the major source has been the mainstream TV channels CNN, NBC, (even) Fox News and websites I have also managed to read some independent blogs and websites from units like MediaMatters.

I like the concept of a party coming up with its Nominee by first going through an election process. The wannabes campaigning within the respective party's support base,debating the issues on television makes the process more vibrant(For argument sake, ignoring the the criticism that News channels are backed by corporate interests or how lobbyists play a big role the process is intended to be more participative)

With the Presidential form of democracy the election is obviously more focused on the individuals, their personality, charisma and of course their gaffes.

While the socio-economic realities in India are different and we have a parliamentary system, it is difficult to say which one is better.I can't even imagine having Televised debates or such debates being of much use in the Indian scenario.But for country which became independent after the Second World War India is an encouraging example of an evolving and successful (people might disagree on the the degree of success)democracy.

And in spite of the differences one can draw parallels -
-Race and to a extent religion is a issue in the US the way vote banks based on caste and religion play a important role in India.
-How the pollsters go wrong be it opinion polls for a Primary or a State election in India.
-How candidates complain about the media being biased to them.

One thing that I have been puzzled by is the seemingly undue coverage given to things like false sniper fire comments, flag-pins, Pastor remarks rather than issues which more important for the ordinary citizen.It might be because these are more newsworthy and eye-catching stories on Prime time. I would like to think that people are more discerning and see beyond such things when making the choices.

As for me I am rooting for Obama.I am impressed by the fresh views he brings to the table and there is a certain genuineness in the man.He has done a great job at leveraging Information Technology for his campaign and the manner in which he seems to be mobilizing the youth(thanks to his oratory skills).For those who point at his inexperience, well the ones with a lot of experience haven't been doing that great a job too !

Be it India, USA, Africa or Europe I think the world needs young politicians.... with a fresh perspective.

While a friend of mine said looking at Obama she was reminded of me...that's not the reason for me supporting him :)

4 comments:

Devendra Rathor said...

A good recap of whatever been happening in last few months in the US of A...
On the debate over which one is better between presidential or parliamentary form of democracy, I had come across a detailed articled by Shahshi Tharoor on the topic and he had summarized in there that a crossbreed between the two systems resembling more like what France follows now would be a better fit in Indian context...though its another story that India can never alter its existing system even if the govt gets 100% public mandate/votes as it seems the basic constitutional structure of India is defined as a mathematical constant so to speak..

Well written and keep them coming...

Anonymous said...

Well, in the Presidential form of government, the existence of sole executive - the President hampers the democratic structure.

In India there is a need to stream line the Parliamtentary system of govt rather than opting for the Presidential form.If there is no sincereity and commitment towards the common good, both the systems may prove ineffective.

Couldn't keep myself away from posting this comment ;)

Gaurav said...

Devendra/Sneha - I strongly think the parliamentary system is more suited to the India realities...with the vastness of the country , the diversity in the socio-economic sphere, a along with the historical baggage of the economically and socially marginalized I feel the parliamentary form is much better system for the redressal of issues...though it may take its time..

Vaidehi Dongre said...

Yup, now that u mentioned, u resemble Obama! I am rooting for Obama too!! GoBama